Tuesday, November 07, 2006

Up to three quarters of young black men will soon have their profiles stored on the British DNA database

Ben Leapman:

An estimated 135,000 black males aged 15 to 34 will be entered in the crime-fighting-database by April, equivalent to as many as 77 per cent of the young black male population in England and Wales. By contrast, only 22 per cent of young white males, and six per cent of the general population, will be on the database.

All arrested crime suspects have their DNA taken and their profile stored for life, even if they are later cleared or the arrest is found to be a case of mistaken identity. Even children under 10 can have their DNA recorded. Mr Phillips disclosed that his officials will investigate whether the policy of retaining DNA from suspects who are never convicted of a crime results in discrimination against black men, who are more likely to come into contact with police than their white counterparts.

"Stop and search statistics suggest that black males are more likely to be stopped simply because they are young black males," he said.

Isn't it possible that they are being stopped because they are breaking the law? Here are the figures:

The figures arise from Home Office projections released to Bob Spink, a Conservative MP, which show that by April 2007 the DNA database will hold 3.7 million profiles, including three million "white-skinned Europeans" and 257,099 "Afro-Caribbeans".

The Home Office could not break down the figures for each ethnic group by age or sex. But, in general, 82 per cent of individuals on the entire database are male, while 64 per cent are aged 15 to 34. It means that, assuming a similar sex and age balance for all ethnic groups, there will be 135,000 young black men on the database next April. Figures for the last census in 2001 showed there were 175,000 black men, aged between 15 and 34, in England and Wales.

The calculation method has been endorsed by experts, including Dr David Owen, of Warwick University's Centre for Research in Ethnic Relations, who described the figures as "disturbingly high".

Henry Potts, a statistician at University College London, said: "The available data points firmly to this conclusion." Dr Potts said, however, it remained slightly unclear how individual police officers record the ethnic group of mixed-race crime suspects.

He pointed out that if some were recorded in the database as Afro-Caribbean, then the true proportion of young black men who are on the database could be below 77 per cent, but confirmed it would still be more than 60 per cent.

Black youths 'in need of fathers'


At 10:29 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Isn't it possible that they are being stopped because they are breaking the law?

Even if not directly doing so at the time, it must be well known by now to all cops that Blacks commit a disproportionate share of crime, and so it is not unlikely that they'd be stopped more often under any sort of 'reasonable suspicion' criteria. Policing that way is just common sense, but unfortunately these days common sense is often labeled as 'profiling' and one way or another prohibited.

One legitimate concern may be that, as I understand it (?), there could be cases where a stop/arrest is made, and therefore a sample is taken/recorded, but in the end no charges are ever filed.


Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

View My Stats